Do accessibility overlays work? What the FTC's 2025 order means for small shops

Published October 2026 · All Reach Audit

If you run a small online store or restaurant website, you've probably seen ads for a one-line "accessibility widget" that promises instant compliance. Here's what those tools are, what regulators said about one of them in 2025, and what tends to work better.

What an overlay is

An overlay is a script added to your site that shows a toolbar (bigger text, contrast toggles and so on) and tries to automatically patch accessibility problems in the browser. The appeal is obvious: one line of code, a monthly fee, and no developer time.

The catch is that the overlay works on top of your site, while the problems live in your site's own code: unlabeled buttons in your theme, product images without descriptions, a menu that can't be opened with a keyboard. Many disabled people already use their own assistive technology (screen readers, magnifiers, switch devices), and a second layer of tools on top can get in their way rather than help. Accessibility practitioners have collected these concerns in the Overlay Fact Sheet.

What the FTC said in 2025

In January 2025 the Federal Trade Commission proposed a complaint against accessiBe, a major overlay vendor. In April 2025 it approved a final order requiring the company to pay $1 million. According to the FTC's announcement:

The FTC alleged the company's widget "did not make all user websites WCAG-compliant", and that its claims were "false, misleading, or unsubstantiated."
The order bars the company from claiming its automated products can make any website WCAG-compliant, or keep it compliant over time, unless it has evidence to support those claims.
The complaint also alleged that third-party reviews and articles were formatted to look independent without disclosing the company's connection to them.

The order concerned one company's marketing claims. It didn't ban overlays, but it's a clear signal that "install this and you're compliant" is a claim regulators are willing to challenge.

Overlays and lawsuits

A widget is also not a reliable shield. Lawsuit trackers report that a meaningful share of sued websites already had an overlay installed. One 2025 analysis, citing EcomBack data, put it at about 22.6% of sites sued in the first half of 2025 (whatisADA.com 2025 review).

What to do instead

Find the real problems. Start with an automated scan, then test by hand with a keyboard and a screen reader, because automated tools only catch part of the picture.
Fix the source. Most common problems, like missing alt text, unlabeled buttons and form fields, and low-contrast text, are small, permanent fixes in your theme or content (see our guide to the most common problems on small Shopify stores).
Keep it fixed. New apps, theme updates and new content can bring problems back, so re-check regularly.
Be honest about where you are. Publish an accessibility statement with a way for customers to report barriers, and respond when they do.

None of this guarantees you'll never get a complaint, and nobody can honestly promise that. It does mean your site actually works better for the customers who rely on it.

Sources

Want to know where your site stands?

Send us your website address and we'll email you a free preliminary scan of a few public pages.

Request a free scan